Mystic Island Homes for Sale

Mystic Island Homes for Sale

Welcome to Mystic Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Ocean County, New Jersey. This charming subdivision offers a unique blend of serene coastal living and vibrant community spirit, making it an ideal destination for families, retirees, and everyone in between. With its picturesque landscapes and tranquil waterways, Mystic Island is a haven for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts alike.

The community is characterized by its friendly atmosphere and welcoming residents, fostering a sense of belonging that is hard to find elsewhere. Residents enjoy easy access to a variety of recreational activities, including boating, fishing, and hiking, all set against the backdrop of stunning natural beauty. Additionally, the nearby beaches provide the perfect escape for sunbathing, swimming, and enjoying the fresh ocean breeze.

When it comes to homes for sale in Mystic Island, you'll find an array of options to suit your lifestyle and budget. From cozy single-family homes to spacious waterfront properties, the real estate offerings cater to diverse preferences. Many homes feature modern amenities, open floor plans, and outdoor spaces ideal for entertaining or simply relaxing after a long day. Whether you're seeking a year-round residence or a seasonal retreat, Mystic Island has something for everyone.

Discover the charm and tranquility of Mystic Island, where your dream home awaits. Explore our listings today and take the first step toward making this enchanting community your own!

Newest Mystic Island Homes for Sale

$689,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to effortless coastal living in this beautifully custom built raised ranch, just 4 years young and thoughtfully designed for making unforgettable Jersey Shore memories. Bright, open, and impeccably maintained, this home offers a spacious floor plan highlighted by luxury vinyl plank flooring, abundant natural light, and a stunning white kitchen featuring granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and plenty of cabinet space. The inviting living room opens through double sliding doors to a waterfront deck, creating the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee, evening sunsets, or entertain family and friends. The home offers three generously sized bedrooms, two full bathrooms, a large laundry room with pantry storage, and direct access from the oversized two car garage into the home for everyday convenience. The fully enclosed ground level provides exceptional storage space, making it easy to keep all of your boating gear, beach toys, and outdoor equipment organized. Outside, you'll find a vinyl fenced backyard, a vinyl bulkhead, and room to dock your boat right outside your door, making every day feel like a vacation. Ideally located near local shopping, restaurants, marinas, and just minutes by boat or car to Osborn Island Bay Beach, Long Beach Island, and Atlantic City, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and waterfront living. Being only four years old, you can move in with confidence knowing the major systems and finishes are modern, stylish, and ready for years of enjoyment.

28 Ship Dr, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty - Atlantic Shore. Contact: 6094849890
$499,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Experience effortless Jersey Shore waterfront living in this beautifully maintained, approximately 1,200 square foot home where pride of ownership shines throughout. Thoughtfully updated and truly move in ready, this bright and spacious open floor plan offers the perfect blend of comfort and coastal charm. Bring your boat, your crab traps, and start enjoying life on the water. Situated in an excellent boating location with easy access to the Great Bay right from your own backyard, this is the waterfront lifestyle you've been dreaming of. The beautifully maintained yard provides the perfect setting to relax, entertain, or simply enjoy the peaceful surroundings. Enjoy sunsets off of the deck over the water. This home features gas forced hot air heat, and a full appliance package. Every major system is in working condition, allowing you to move in with confidence and peace of mind. Ideally located just minutes from Long Beach Island, Atlantic City, the Garden State Parkway, public transportation, regional shopping, and a wide variety of restaurants, this exceptional property offers convenience, recreation, and coastal living at its finest. All that's missing is you and your belongings. Come make this beautiful Jersey Shore waterfront home your own private paradise.

15 W Mullica Rd, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty - Atlantic Shore. Contact: 6094849890
$429,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Experience the waterfront lifestyle you’ve been dreaming of in the heart of Mystic Island, one of the Jersey Shore’s hidden gems. Celebrated for its world-class fishing, rich maritime history, and incredible waterfront value, this thriving community continues to attract buyers seeking deep-water access, newer homes, and an unbeatable coastal lifestyle. Positioned on one of Mystic Island’s coveted east-side deep-water lagoons, this property offers the depth serious boaters appreciate for effortless navigation. Step outside into a backyard that’s truly in a class of its own. With tens of thousands invested in the exterior, this private oasis features a sparkling sub-in-ground pool, an impressive piling-supported waterfront unlike any other on the lagoon, and beautifully curated landscaping that welcomes Monarch butterflies back year after year. Whether you’re watching the sunrise with coffee, entertaining family and friends by the pool, or cruising out for a day on the bay, this is more than a home; it’s a place where unforgettable memories are made. Minutes from Long Beach Island, Atlantic City, dining, beaches, and some of New Jersey’s best boating and fishing, this is your chance to own a piece of the Jersey Shore lifestyle.

109 E Mohawk Dr, Tuckerton

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Preferred Properties. Contact: 6093247600
$626,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to 2 Spar Court, where coastal luxury meets effortless waterfront living in the highly sought-after Mystic Island community. Perfectly positioned on a beautifully manicured corner lot at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, this meticulously maintained raised ranch offers 1,656 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, 3 spacious bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and 65 feet of prime canal frontage complete with a private bulkhead and floating dock—creating the ideal setting for boaters and those who dream of life on the water. Step inside to discover a bright, open-concept floor plan enhanced by ceramic tile and gleaming hardwood flooring throughout. The spacious living and dining areas flow seamlessly into a beautifully appointed kitchen featuring rich custom wood cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, a center island with seating, and abundant storage, making it equally suited for everyday living and entertaining. Multiple exterior doors invite natural light inside while providing effortless access to the expansive rear deck that stretches the entire length of the home, offering the perfect place to enjoy morning coffee, evening cocktails, or breathtaking sunset views over the canal. The private primary suite is a true retreat, complete with its own access to the rear deck, generous closet space, and an ensuite bathroom featuring a soaking tub with shower, bidet, and an updated vanity. Two additional well-proportioned bedrooms provide comfortable accommodations for family and guests, while the second full bath is tastefully updated with a modern vanity and tub/shower combination. The lower level is where this home truly separates itself from the competition. The entire under-house area has been enclosed, creating an enormous garage, workshop, storage area, and recreation space with endless possibilities for car enthusiasts, hobbyists, fitness equipment, watercraft storage, or future customization. Outside, the covered brick paver patio beneath the deck offers a shaded outdoor entertaining area just steps from your private dock, making waterfront gatherings effortless. Whether you're searching for a year-round residence, a luxurious shore retreat, or the ultimate boating destination, 2 Spar Court delivers the perfect combination of quality construction, spacious living, exceptional storage, and an unbeatable waterfront lifestyle—all just minutes from the open bay, local marinas, dining, and the Jersey Shore's finest beaches. This is Mystic Island living at its absolute best. Schedule your private tour today!

2 Spar Ct, Tuckerton

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty - Washington Township. Contact: (856) 582-1200
$799,900
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Welcome to coastal living at its finest! Custom built in 2014 with quality 2x6 construction, this elevated two story home was thoughtfully designed for comfort, efficiency, and life on the water. Offering five spacious bedrooms and three full bathrooms, this home features ceramic tile flooring, custom built in closet storage, and room darkening blinds and shades throughout. Every bedroom and living space is equipped with its own ductless mini split system, allowing personalized climate control, while electric baseboard heat provides additional backup comfort. A tankless water heater adds to the home's energy efficiency. The kitchen comes complete with a stainless steel appliance package and flows effortlessly into the living spaces, making it ideal for entertaining family and friends. Outside, you'll find everything you need to enjoy the waterfront lifestyle. Relax on the enclosed screened porch, entertain on the trex deck, cool off in the above ground pool, or rinse off after a day on the water in the outdoor shower. The fully vinyl fenced yard offers privacy along with a storage shed and plenty of room for all your outdoor gear. Boaters will appreciate the vinyl bulkhead, floating dock, and quick ride to the open bay, where breathtaking sunsets await. The boat, jet skis, and jet ski dock are negotiable, making this an incredible opportunity for anyone looking to start enjoying the waterfront immediately. The oversized garage is truly exceptional, featuring custom flooring, abundant storage space, and a screened garage door that creates the perfect place to relax, entertain, or work on projects while enjoying the coastal breeze. Conveniently located close to regional shopping, restaurants, and everything the Jersey Shore has to offer, this one of a kind waterfront home combines quality craftsmanship, thoughtful upgrades, and an unbeatable boating location. Schedule your private tour today and experience everything this exceptional property has to offer.

17 Portland Dr, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty - Atlantic Shore. Contact: 6094849890
$899,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
**NEW LISTING ALERT**Discover the pinnacle of coastal living at 6 W Brig Dr, where you can start your day with coffee on the upper deck while listening to the tranquil sounds of the lagoon. Tailor-made for boating aficionados, this residence boasts a 50’ vinyl bulkhead with an electric boat lift, ensuring you can reach the open bay in a mere 15 minutes. Host gatherings with ease as visitors flow from the 12’x27’ patio into the versatile, 400-square-foot finished garage, which integrates with the exterior via a chic glass roll-up door. The home's center is a sun-drenched, open-concept floor plan anchored by a chef-ready kitchen complete with top-tier GE Café appliances, quartz surfaces, and a spacious island. Take in sweeping water vistas from the balcony or through the energy-conscious, Hunter Douglas-fitted windows. Combining sophisticated elegance with a laid-back shore aesthetic, this property offers a permanent, vacation-style retreat.

6 W Brig Dr W, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Atlantic. Contact: 6096418600
$425,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to 28 Lake Saint Clair Drive, a charming coastal retreat nestled in the heart of Mystic Islands. This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 1-bath waterfront is filled with abundant natural light and features fresh, light tile flooring throughout, creating a bright, airy atmosphere that is both inviting and move-in ready. One of the home's standout features is the spacious bonus room/three-season sunroom, offering an open, light-filled living space surrounded by walls of sliding glass doors. This stunning room seamlessly brings the outdoors in, showcasing tranquil views, creating the perfect setting for morning coffee, entertaining, or simply unwinding while enjoying the peaceful scenery year-round. The natural lagoon view provides exceptional privacy and a serene backdrop, enhancing the home's waterfront ambiance. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, a weekend escape, or the perfect Jersey Shore vacation home, this delightful property offers comfort, versatility, and the relaxed coastal lifestyle Mystic Islands is known for. Conveniently located near marinas, restaurants, shopping, and just a short drive to the beaches of Long Beach Island, or Atlantic City, this is your opportunity to own a slice of the Jersey Shore.

28 Lake Saint Clair Dr, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Murphy & Co.. Contact: 6092077297
$349,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Charming 2 Bedroom, 1 Bath Ranch Approximately 1,050 Sq. Ft. Move right into this beautifully maintained ranch that's full of charm and tasteful updates! Featuring an inviting open floor plan, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort and style. Features You'll Love: • Beautiful wood floors throughout the living room and bedrooms • Spacious open concept layout with a stylish accent wall • Updated kitchen with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and abundant cabinetry • Gas forced hot air heat and central air conditioning • Tastefully updated and meticulously maintained • Situated on a 60 x 100 lot with room to enjoy the outdoors, fenced yard, patio & shed. Conveniently located just minutes from the Jersey Shore beaches, marinas, shopping, restaurants, and everything the Mystic Island area has to offer. Whether you're looking for a year round home, vacation getaway, or investment opportunity, this one is a must see!

228 Lake Champlain Dr, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty - Atlantic Shore. Contact: 6094849890
$350,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Bring your paintbrushes and some fresh ideas! Original Sportsman model that has been loved by the family since 1963. Super affordable home on a great lagoon very close to open water. Wonderful potential. Great opportunity to obtain a lagoon front home on a great street at the Jersey Shore. Minutes from the Garden State Parkway. Minutes to Atlantic City, Brigantine, or Long Beach Island. Short walk to the Italian American Club (you don't have to be Italian to join) as well as several other restaurants. Just down the road from the Radio Road Bay Beach. Shopping is nearby. Low taxes. Don't miss out because there just are not that many of these older homes that you can use now and fix up over time or just rebuild later in a great location!

40 W Anchor Dr, Tuckerton

Listing courtesy of Mezzina Agency. Contact: 6092968116
$675,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Recently remodeled. Features include an elevator, backup generator, 65 vinyl bulkhead on lagoon, quick access to bay, ample lighting back yard and dock area, large shed with power, large deck area, summer kitchen and bar at ground level, oversize lot, special lighting and sound packages, gourmet kitchen, so much more! Welcome to your waterfront retreat on an oversize lot with a wide lagoon in desirable Mystic Island! This well-maintained, move-in-ready home offers the perfect blend of comfort, space, and coastal living. The main level features a welcoming living room, a spacious dining area with sliding doors leading to a large deck overlooking the backyard and beautiful lagoon views, and a generously sized gourmet kitchen with abundant cabinetry and granite counter space plus an island. Three comfortable bedrooms and two full bathrooms complete the main floor. Interior stairs or the elevator takes you down to first level. The lower level provides additional living space with room for a fourth bedroom, a large entertainment/family room, a laundry area, and access to the oversized garage. Kitchenette and bar with sliders opening to the spacious yard and the lagoon. The expansive driveway offers plenty of room for multiple vehicles and your boat. Step outside and enjoy the peaceful waterfront setting, spectacular sunsets, and endless opportunities for boating, fishing, crabbing, kayaking, paddleboarding, and jet skiing right from your own backyard. A vinyl bulkhead, installed in 2021, adds lasting value and peace of mind. Whether you're searching for a year-round residence, vacation getaway, weekend retreat, or investment property with rental potential, this exceptional waterfront home is ready for you to start making memories on the Jersey Shore. Fully remodeled recently, vacant and ready for the summer.

112 Potomac, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of Mezzina Agency. Contact: 6092968116
$459,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to 22 N Forecastle Drive in the desirable Mystic Islands waterfront community. This clean and well-maintained 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom home offers comfortable coastal living with direct lagoon access. The wide lagoon provides plenty of room to enjoy boating, kayaking, fishing, or simply relaxing by the water. Inside, you will find a flexible bonus room that works well as a home office, hobby room, or additional storage space. Located on a quiet street, this home is a great opportunity for year-round living, a weekend getaway, or an investment property. Come see everything waterfront living in Little Egg Harbor has to offer.

22 N Forecastle Dr, Tuckerton

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Preferred Properties. Contact: 6095976700
$510,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to this charming coastal retreat on a wide lagoon in Mystic Island, where waterfront living meets comfort and relaxation. This beautifully maintained, move-in-ready home offers generous space both inside and out, perfect for entertaining or enjoying peaceful water views. The main level features a warm and inviting living room, a dining area that opens directly to a spacious deck overlooking the backyard and serene waterfront vistas, and a brand new well-appointed kitchen with abundant cabinetry and beautiful quartz countertop. This floor also includes three comfortable bedrooms and two full bathrooms. The lower level expands your living options with an additional bedroom, a laundry area, and a versatile entertainment or recreation room—ideal for guests, extended stays, or casual gatherings. Outside, the property truly shines. Enjoy an oversized six car concrete driveway with ample room for boats, multiple vehicles, and all your recreational needs, along with a generous outdoor space designed for coastal living. From sunrise coffee to sunset views over the water, this home offers a rare blend of tranquility and lifestyle. With direct access to endless water activities—swimming, paddle boating, jet skiing, fishing, and more—your backyard becomes your personal waterfront playground. Whether you're seeking a year-round residence, weekend getaway, vacation home, or investment property, this home delivers exceptional flexibility and appeal. Vinyl bulkhead installed in 2021.

17 Delaware W, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of Mezzina Agency. Contact: 6092968116
Start Your Search