Mystic Island Homes for Sale

Mystic Island Homes for Sale

Welcome to Mystic Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Ocean County, New Jersey. This charming subdivision offers a unique blend of serene coastal living and vibrant community spirit, making it an ideal destination for families, retirees, and everyone in between. With its picturesque landscapes and tranquil waterways, Mystic Island is a haven for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts alike.

The community is characterized by its friendly atmosphere and welcoming residents, fostering a sense of belonging that is hard to find elsewhere. Residents enjoy easy access to a variety of recreational activities, including boating, fishing, and hiking, all set against the backdrop of stunning natural beauty. Additionally, the nearby beaches provide the perfect escape for sunbathing, swimming, and enjoying the fresh ocean breeze.

When it comes to homes for sale in Mystic Island, you'll find an array of options to suit your lifestyle and budget. From cozy single-family homes to spacious waterfront properties, the real estate offerings cater to diverse preferences. Many homes feature modern amenities, open floor plans, and outdoor spaces ideal for entertaining or simply relaxing after a long day. Whether you're seeking a year-round residence or a seasonal retreat, Mystic Island has something for everyone.

Discover the charm and tranquility of Mystic Island, where your dream home awaits. Explore our listings today and take the first step toward making this enchanting community your own!

Newest Mystic Island Homes for Sale

$349,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath ranch situated on a level 60x100 lot in the heart of Mystic Island! This adorable home offers a comfortable, easy-living floor plan with beautiful hardwood flooring throughout the living room and bedrooms, a quaint eat-in kitchen, Anderson windows, and newer appliances. Additional features include gas forced-air heating, an approximately 8-year-old roof, low taxes, and the home is being offered furnished making it easy to unpack, settle in, and start enjoying the Jersey Shore lifestyle! Outside, you'll find a fully fenced yard and an amazing detached one-car garage that offers so much more than just parking. Complete with a subpanel, insulation, heating, and cooling, this versatile space has fantastic potential for a workshop, hobby room, home gym, game room, or the ultimate hangout space. Whether you're looking for a year-round home or a cute little Jersey Shore getaway, this one is ready for you to make it your own. Conveniently located near local marinas, restaurants, shopping, public transportation, and all the recreation the area has to offer. Come take a peek you may have just found your new shore house!

137 National Union Blvd, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty - Atlantic Shore. Contact: 6094849890
$549,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to Osborn Island! This well-cared-for 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch is ready for its new owner. Offering comfortable one-level living and a great coastal location, this home is ideal for year-round living or your Jersey Shore getaway. Boaters will appreciate the easy-to-navigate access to the bay, making it simple to get out on the water and enjoy everything the area has to offer. Whether you're looking for a primary residence, weekend retreat, or shore investment, this Osborn Island home is ready for its next chapter.

19 Louisiana Dr, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Real Estate-Allentown. Contact: 6107709000
$1,175,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Life at 7 W Navasink is built around the water. Just minutes from the open bay, this beautifully designed lagoon-front home offers the space to gather, the privacy to unwind and the waterfront access to make every day feel like summer. Start the morning with coffee on one of three lagoon-front decks, spend the afternoon boating from your private dock and electric boat lift, then come home to sweeping water views and relaxed indoor-outdoor living. At the heart of the home is an incredible kitchen with a six-burner commercial range, wall oven, quartz countertops and backsplash, and a built-in Miele coffee center. The open living area features a gas fireplace and plenty of room for family and friends. The primary suite feels like a private retreat of its own, with a generous sitting area, two oversized walk-in closets, a luxurious bath with a clawfoot tub and double shower, and a private waterfront deck. An elevator serves all three levels, while laundry rooms on both living floors make everyday life easier. The ground level adds even more flexibility with a bonus room currently used as an office, a mudroom and incredible spaces for relaxing and entertaining. With rear-access garage doors, an outdoor shower, water and electric at the dock, and room for everyone to enjoy the shore, this is more than a waterfront house...it is a place designed for the way people truly want to live at the Jersey Shore.

7 W Navasink Dr, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of SERHANT. New Jersey LLC. Contact: 6094942800
$550,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
This home is situated on an awesome street that offers a wide lagoon. This home is the one that you were looking for with 3 spacious bedrooms. This includes an expansive Primary Suite complete w/ a full Bathroom & a plenty of closet space. The entire back of the house has vaulted ceilings in the Great Room and Dining Room with custom windows and direct access to the rear 31-foot deck through multiple Andersen Sliders. What an awesome space to congregate & start making those Jersey shore memories with friends and family! There is a huge, updated kitchen with granite countertops/SS Appliance package/36-inchcustom cabinets/subway backsplash. You will also find near the 2 spacious bedrooms an updated main bath. Worth noting the HVAC was replaced in 2025 & the roof was replaced in 2023.

33 W Mullica Rd, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Classic Group. Contact: (908) 231-0700
$475,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Waterfront living at its best in Mystic Island! This turn-key FURNISHED 2 bedroom, 1-bath coastal ranch delivers effortless lagoon frontage with prime boating access to Great Bay and beyond. Peace of mind comes built-in with major capital improvements already complete, including a 3-year-old roof and a 2-year-old A/C unit. Inside, the main home features a clean, functional layout with comfortable bedrooms, an efficient kitchen, and a refreshed full bath ready for immediate move-in. Towards the water, step into the expansive rear addition—a showstopping living space boasting soaring vaulted ceilings and generous windows that flood the room with natural light, creating the ideal hub for entertaining. Step outside to a shaded waterfront backyard that keeps you cool through the peak of summer, complemented by a carefree vinyl bulkhead and floating dock ready for your boat, jet skis, and weekend crabbing. Complete with a low-maintenance 50x100 lot and ample driveway parking, this home is the ultimate low-stress primary residence or weekend bay retreat. Schedule your private tour today!

26 W Potomac Dr, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty - Ocean City. Contact: (609) 399-5454
$425,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
STEP INTO YOUR OWN STORYBOOK!!!!!!! With its charming character , whimsical details, and fairy tale-like appeal. This enchanted home feels like its plucked from a magical book. Reminiscent of a cozy gingerbread cottage, this one- of- a-kind home is full of warmth personality, and magical charm around every corner. This home is four foot plus raised on almost quarter acre. Situated on 2 Lagoon fronts with its own boat ramp overlooking undisturbed and protected meadows. Outdoor shower cabana. Newer roof, plumbing, electric, A/C, heat and appliance package . Plenty of storage under home. Extend your dreams for the endless possibilities this unique property has to offer.

152 S Captains Dr, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of Anchor Homes Real Estate. Contact: (609) 879-3502
$345,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Waterfront opportunity located on a great street in Little Egg Harbor! House has 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, plus a sunroom, living room, great room, and attached garage. Property has a letter of substantial damage from the township. Inquire for more information.

14 S Boston Dr, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of Century 21 Action Plus Realty - Manahawkin. Contact: 8002992129
$475,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to 17 W Sail Drive, a waterfront gem in Mystic Island (Little Egg Harbor)! This amazing 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers the perfect opportunity to embrace the laid-back Jersey Shore lifestyle with waterfront living right in your backyard. Step inside and discover a comfortable, inviting home with a layout designed for easy everyday living and entertaining. The true star of the property is the waterfront setting—imagine starting your mornings with beautiful water views, spending afternoons enjoying the outdoors, and ending your day watching the sun go down over the water. Whether you’re looking for a year-round home, weekend getaway, or investment opportunity, this property offers the perfect combination of location, lifestyle, and potential. Enjoy boating, fishing, kayaking, and everything the Mystic Island waterfront has to offer, all while being close to local beaches, restaurants, marinas, and the best of the Jersey Shore. Three bedrooms. One bath. Waterfront. Endless possibilities. Come see why 17 W Sail Drive could be your next home at the shore

17 W Sail Dr, Mystic Islands

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty - Moorestown. Contact: (856) 316-1100
$424,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Experience waterfront living in Mystic Island, one of the Jersey Shore's hidden gems—known for world-class fishing, maritime history, and unbeatable coastal value. Set on a coveted east-side deep-water lagoon, this home offers the depth serious boaters need for effortless navigation. The backyard is a private oasis, with tens of thousands invested in exterior upgrades: a sparkling sub-in-ground pool, low-maintenance decking, vinyl bulkhead, and lush perennial gardens that draw Monarch butterflies back each year. Outdoor plugs service both the dock and pool with ease. Inside, enjoy a dual-icemaker WiFi refrigerator, a high-heat 5-burner self-cleaning stove that boils water fast, and a WiFi-enabled lighted dishwasher, plus large attached storage. Minutes from LBI, Atlantic City, beaches, dining, and top boating and fishing spots—this is your chance to own a piece of the Jersey Shore lifestyle.

109 E Mohawk Dr, Tuckerton

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Preferred Properties. Contact: 6093247600
$626,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to 2 Spar Court, where coastal luxury meets effortless waterfront living in the highly sought-after Mystic Island community. Perfectly positioned on a beautifully manicured corner lot at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, this meticulously maintained raised ranch offers 1,656 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, 3 spacious bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and 65 feet of prime canal frontage complete with a private bulkhead and floating dock—creating the ideal setting for boaters and those who dream of life on the water. Step inside to discover a bright, open-concept floor plan enhanced by ceramic tile and gleaming hardwood flooring throughout. The spacious living and dining areas flow seamlessly into a beautifully appointed kitchen featuring rich custom wood cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, a center island with seating, and abundant storage, making it equally suited for everyday living and entertaining. Multiple exterior doors invite natural light inside while providing effortless access to the expansive rear deck that stretches the entire length of the home, offering the perfect place to enjoy morning coffee, evening cocktails, or breathtaking sunset views over the canal. The private primary suite is a true retreat, complete with its own access to the rear deck, generous closet space, and an ensuite bathroom featuring a soaking tub with shower, bidet, and an updated vanity. Two additional well-proportioned bedrooms provide comfortable accommodations for family and guests, while the second full bath is tastefully updated with a modern vanity and tub/shower combination. The lower level is where this home truly separates itself from the competition. The entire under-house area has been enclosed, creating an enormous garage, workshop, storage area, and recreation space with endless possibilities for car enthusiasts, hobbyists, fitness equipment, watercraft storage, or future customization. Outside, the covered brick paver patio beneath the deck offers a shaded outdoor entertaining area just steps from your private dock, making waterfront gatherings effortless. Whether you're searching for a year-round residence, a luxurious shore retreat, or the ultimate boating destination, 2 Spar Court delivers the perfect combination of quality construction, spacious living, exceptional storage, and an unbeatable waterfront lifestyle—all just minutes from the open bay, local marinas, dining, and the Jersey Shore's finest beaches. This is Mystic Island living at its absolute best. Schedule your private tour today!

2 Spar Ct, Tuckerton

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty - Washington Township. Contact: (856) 582-1200
$899,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
**NEW LISTING ALERT**Discover the pinnacle of coastal living at 6 W Brig Dr, where you can start your day with coffee on the upper deck while listening to the tranquil sounds of the lagoon. Tailor-made for boating aficionados, this residence boasts a 50’ vinyl bulkhead with an electric boat lift, ensuring you can reach the open bay in a mere 15 minutes. Host gatherings with ease as visitors flow from the 12’x27’ patio into the versatile, 400-square-foot finished garage, which integrates with the exterior via a chic glass roll-up door. The home's center is a sun-drenched, open-concept floor plan anchored by a chef-ready kitchen complete with top-tier GE Café appliances, quartz surfaces, and a spacious island. Take in sweeping water vistas from the balcony or through the energy-conscious, Hunter Douglas-fitted windows. Combining sophisticated elegance with a laid-back shore aesthetic, this property offers a permanent, vacation-style retreat.

6 W Brig Dr W, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Atlantic. Contact: 6096418600
$425,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to 28 Lake Saint Clair Drive, a charming coastal retreat nestled in the heart of Mystic Islands. This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 1-bath waterfront is filled with abundant natural light and features fresh, light tile flooring throughout, creating a bright, airy atmosphere that is both inviting and move-in ready. One of the home's standout features is the spacious bonus room/three-season sunroom, offering an open, light-filled living space surrounded by walls of sliding glass doors. This stunning room seamlessly brings the outdoors in, showcasing tranquil views, creating the perfect setting for morning coffee, entertaining, or simply unwinding while enjoying the peaceful scenery year-round. The natural lagoon view provides exceptional privacy and a serene backdrop, enhancing the home's waterfront ambiance. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, a weekend escape, or the perfect Jersey Shore vacation home, this delightful property offers comfort, versatility, and the relaxed coastal lifestyle Mystic Islands is known for. Conveniently located near marinas, restaurants, shopping, and just a short drive to the beaches of Long Beach Island, or Atlantic City, this is your opportunity to own a slice of the Jersey Shore.

28 Lake Saint Clair Dr, Little Egg Harbor Twp

Listing courtesy of Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Murphy & Co.. Contact: 6092077297
Start Your Search