Refine Search
Sort by
$2,075,000
5 Beds 6 Baths
Welcome to 257 Chicagami Trail, a beautifully renovated lakefront home in the heart of Medford Lakes. Situated on a large lot overlooking Upper Aetna Lake, this expansive property offers five bedrooms, four full bathrooms, two half bathrooms, and a rare combination of updated finishes, generous living space, and direct lake access. Inside, the home features an updated eat-in kitchen with newer appliances, a sunken den, gas fireplace, recessed lighting, renovated bathrooms, and high-end finishes throughout. A newer roof and newer heating and air-conditioning systems provide additional peace of mind. The home also includes an approximately 1,530-square-foot unfinished basement with a separate entrance, an additional washer, and excellent potential for storage or future living space. Outside, enjoy lakefront views from the large upper deck, which leads down to a private dock and built-in fire pit—perfect for entertaining or relaxing by the water. The property also includes a lake mucker for cleaning and maintaining the lakefront area. The sprawling front yard and spacious U-shaped driveway complete this exceptional Medford Lakes property.

257 Chicagami Trl, Medford Lakes

Listing courtesy of Diamond Realty Associates. Contact: 7325481900

$1,890,000
5 Beds 3 Baths
Original owner, Dr. Edward from Philadelphia built this cabin in 1927 on Ballinger Lake with 200 ft of water frontage.. He extended the lot into the lake and added to the sandy beach . This home is one of the first 10 homes to be built in the colony and has one of the largest most private wooded lakefront lots. There are lake views from all rooms as well as over 40 custom windows throughout the house. Originally the home was built as a summer retreat, and it has one of the largest stone fireplaces with original hanging hooked black kettle known as a fireplace crane. This home features 5 bedrooms and 3 full baths, open spaced kitchen for all your entertaining & culinary needs, a oversized family room or what was considered a lodge room, and upper hallway with large balcony that overlooks this grand space. In 2007, Copper Rust Versailles slate floors were installed & encompass the entire first floor. In the same year, the Carriage home on the property was fully renovated to a 1 full bedroom, 1 full bathroom, laundry room, as well as upper level family room with wood burning stove and full size kitchen. There is also additional storage space created in areas around the carriage home and another wood cabin shed was constructed on the property. The kitchen was fully renovated with raw edge countertops and butlers pantry with original door from one of the rooms of the old Settlers Inn where PJ Whelihans now stands. There is also a new HVAC, hot water heater & water softener system. Entire ceiling of the lodge room area was rebuilt. Exquisite primary suite was added on first level with luxurious custom bathroom raw edge countertops. Claw foot soaking tub, with fireplace as well as a grand walk in stone and pebble shower with overhead rainfall shower head. A salt water swimming pool & pond with waterfall was added with privacy fencing with pavilion & outdoor fireplace, bulkhead , beach by the lake as well as a outdoor shower out of a story book with a massive tree in the heart of the shower with natural stone. You have to see this to believe it! It is simply unique to this property. Schedule your tour today. Walking distance to Cathedral of the Woods Community Chapel, Beach 1 & 3, dining at PJ Whelihans , as well as Lakes Coffee, The Sand Stand Ice Cream Parlor, Two Fish & Honey Post.

24 Minnetonka Trl, Medford Lakes

Listing courtesy of EXP Realty, LLC. Contact:

$1,549,000
4 Beds 3 Baths
Step into the quintessential Medford Lakes lifestyle at 15 Cayuga Trail, where rustic charm meets modern comfort in one of the area’s most beloved settings. This home perfectly captures the spirit of the community, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels like a year-round retreat. Remodeled Cape Cod on Upper Aetna Lake in Medford Lakes! Located at end of the trail, with easy access to Area 5, attached 2 car garage with ample paved driveway parking. Covered front porch entry into foyer with open floor plan. Living room with oversized fireplace, game room with sliders to deck and lake, butler pantry with refrigerator, dishwasher and sink located right off of the formal dining room. Kitchen open to family room - all updated. Main floor primary suite with full bath and walk in closet. Main floor also has a powder room and the laundry room. Upper level has 3 bedrooms, Jack and Jill bath, office, game room, sitting area - very flexible space that can be used for whatever your needs may be. Back yard has a spacious deck, hot tub, grassy yard, secret garden, and lake views with your own private dock. The house may have been built in the 50's, but it was rehabbed in the 2020's. A rare Medford Lakes lakefront! The interior is bathed in natural light, highlighting thoughtful finishes and a layout designed for effortless living. You’ll find cozy spaces to unwind and a seamless flow that makes hosting friends a breeze. Outside, the property embraces its natural surroundings, providing a peaceful backdrop for morning coffee on the deck or evening gatherings under the stars. Living here means more than just owning a home; it’s about embracing a unique way of life. Medford Lakes is renowned for its vibrant lake culture, and from this location, you are perfectly positioned to enjoy everything the community has to offer. Spend your days exploring the nearby lakes, making use of the local beaches, or taking advantage of the extensive trail systems. Whether you’re interested in kayaking, community events, or simply enjoying the serene, wooded environment, this home serves as your private gateway to it all. Don’t miss the chance to become part of this one-of-a-kind lakeside enclave.

15 Cayuga Trl, Medford Lakes

Listing courtesy of Compass New Jersey, LLC - Moorestown. Contact: (856) 214-2639

$699,999
4 Beds 3 Baths
This exceptionally renovated home at 37 Osage Trail in Medford Lakes offers a fresh start, having been taken down to the studs. Beyond its beautiful interior, all mechanical systems are brand new, including a high-efficiency HVAC, a new well with a top-tier submersible pump (allowing you to shower and water the lawn simultaneously!), a new sewer line, new windows, a new roof, and even a new driveway and walkway. Step inside to an eat-in kitchen featuring crisp white cabinets, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and an oversized sink with a charming view of Birchwood Lake. The cozy, step-down family room invites relaxation with its wood-burning fireplace and another lovely lake view. For convenience, a half bath and a spacious laundry room, complete with a full size "set it and forget it" washer and dryer (yes all in one) are located off the family room, with direct access to the driveway. Upon entry, an expansive living room perfect for both relaxation and entertaining is light and bright overlooking the front yard, and to the left, a versatile office or fifth bedroom with a closet awaits. The dining room, open to both the kitchen and living room, simplifies entertaining. Upstairs, the large primary bedroom boasts a dressing area, a walk-in closet, and an additional closet. Its handsome en suite bath features a tile shower. Three other generously sized bedrooms and a hall bath with a tiled tub/shower combination complete the second floor. The location is truly unbeatable: step out the back door and you're in Birchwood Lakes, or walk out the front and you're just a minute from Wilson Field, offering a new tot lot and ball fields. This prime spot allows you to fully embrace all that Medford Lakes has to offer. Seller will provide Colony Bond at closing.

37 Osage Tr., Medford Lakes

Listing courtesy of BHHS Fox & Roach-Medford. Contact: 6096541888

$499,900
4 Beds 2 Baths
Welcome to 228 Mckendimen Road, a charming 4-bed, 2-bath home in the highly sought after town of Medford Lakes! Ideally situated directly across from Medford Lakes Country Club and within walking distance to several beautiful beaches and lakes, this home offers an incredible opportunity to enjoy all that the area has to offer. Inside, you'll find beautiful hardwood floors, a welcoming front sunroom, and a spacious great room highlighted by a stunning oversized stone fireplace, creating the perfect gathering space for family and friends. With four bedrooms, two full bathrooms, and a desirable location surrounded by nature, recreation, and local amenities, this home offers the perfect blend of character, comfort, and convenience. Come see all that 228 Mckendimen has to offer - schedule your private showing today!

228 Mckendimen Rd, Medford Lakes

Listing courtesy of EXP Realty, LLC. Contact: